An aerial view shows Italian cruise ship Costa Atlantica, in Nagasaki, southern Japan April 21, 2020. in this photo taken by Kyodo. Picture taken April 21, 2020. Mandatory credit Kyodo/via REUTERS

How Lax Guidelines, Missed Warnings Led to Japan’s Second Coronavirus Cruise-ship Hotspot

Seven days earlier than Japan quarantined a cruise ship close to Tokyo early this yr, in what turned one of many first coronavirus sizzling spots exterior China, one other cruise ship docked in southern Japan.

For the following 5 weeks, because the virus took maintain in Japan and the Diamond Princess in Yokohama port grabbed world consideration, the Japanese authorities issued no warnings to the Costa Atlantica 1,200 km (750 miles) to the southwest.

Passengers from the Yokohama ship had been dying whereas individuals from the opposite vessel freely acquired on and off, eating and purchasing in Nagasaki, and dozens of latest crew members had been flown in to interchange these whose work contracts had been expiring.

The Costa Atlantica now hosts one among Japan’s largest clusters of the coronavirus, which contaminated one-fourth of the greater than 600 individuals then on board.

Public-health consultants say a scarcity of extra measures on cruise ships after the Diamond Princess outbreak, toothless coronavirus laws and a nationwide paucity of virus testing mixed to permit the outbreak on the Costa Atlantica to blossom.

This was compounded by native and nationwide authorities’ resolution to corral contaminated and uninfected individuals on the Costa Atlantica, making it more durable to stem the on-board an infection.

“It appears that evidently a scenario much like the Diamond Princess is being created,” mentioned Dr Amesh Adalja, an infectious-disease specialist on the Johns Hopkins Heart for Well being Safety. “In an effort to maintain circumstances from disembarking, extra circumstances will happen among the many (individuals on board), a few of which could possibly be extreme and preventable.”

The legislation authorising Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s nationwide state of emergency and restrictions on motion by numerous regional governors carries few authorized penalties, a part of Japan’s postwar aversion to curbs on private liberties. It depends as a substitute on social stress and respect for authority. The dearth of widespread testing or infection-tracing apps in Japan complicates the response in Nagasaki. Well being officers say they’re struggling to hint an infection routes and have no idea how the virus unfold to the ship.

Abe’s authorities defends its cautious testing insurance policies, saying it needs to keep away from swamping hospitals with individuals who have solely mild circumstances. And whereas the virus has unfold steadily, infections didn’t spike in Japan, as in some nations, and new circumstances have slowed since mid-April. Japan had confirmed about 15,000 coronavirus infections as of Tuesday, and 543 persons are identified to have died from COVID-19.

The Diamond Princess, which had greater than 3,700 individuals on board, initially stored all of them on the ship, contributing to the unfold of infections to greater than 700 and the deaths of 14.

The 86,000-tonne Italian-flagged Costa Atlantica carried no passengers when it docked for upkeep in Nagasaki. Of the preliminary 623 crew on the ship, 149 examined constructive and 5 of these have been hospitalised.

That makes it one among Japan’s largest clusters, in response to Reuters calculations based mostly on Oxford College information.

The Costa Atlantica and the Diamond Princess are each in the end operated by Florida-based Carnival Corp.

“Sick crew members ought to be totally handled at native hospitals, however wholesome crew ought to be returned to their house nations as quickly as doable,” mentioned Takanori Hamasaki, head of a neighborhood residents’ affiliation.

“I feel those that examined damaging can flip constructive whereas they’re staying on the ship,” Hamasaki advised Reuters in late April. “Truthfully, their cabins on the ship are small – nobody can keep wholesome in that scenario.”

About two weeks after the primary case was detected, operator Costa Cruises started flying wholesome crew members house. By Tuesday, 181 principally Indonesians and Filipinos crew had been repatriated, the native authorities mentioned.

There was no resolution whether or not to repatriate individuals who check constructive, mentioned Katsumi Nakata, a senior official with Nagasaki prefecture. Costa Cruises mentioned in an announcement, “The well being and security of our individuals, together with compliance and environmental safety, is all the time our utmost precedence.”

The Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd unit that operates the Koyagi shipyard the place the Costa Atlantica is docked, apologised to native residents late final month for “inflicting concern” and “misunderstanding” over the outbreak and mentioned it might “totally cooperate” with the authorities.

Kunio Shiiba, a senior govt at Mitsubishi Heavy, bowing deeply at a information convention, additionally apologised for inadequate rationalization in regards to the crew members’ motion.

Costa Cruises manages well being checks of the crew and their motion on and off the ship, whereas Mitsubishi controls the shipyard entrance and checks the temperature of these coming in, Shiiba mentioned.

Hamasaki of the residents’ affiliation mentioned that whereas Mitsubishi apologised to them and defined the steps it had taken, the corporate provided no particular steps to keep away from additional an infection.

“What we are able to do is wash our palms and put on masks,” he mentioned. “That is going to be a protracted battle. If it drags on, it is going to be an issue for all of Japan, not simply in Nagasaki.”


The Costa Atlantica, diverted from virus-ravaged China, docked in Nagasaki on Jan. 29, 5 days earlier than the Diamond Princess moored in Yokohama, the place an infection unfold quickly and the ship was locked down.

On March 6, a month earlier than Abe declared the state of emergency, the Nagasaki authorities requested individuals to remain house, however native companies remained open, attracting clients like Sara Zhou, a Costa Atlantica guest-services worker who sampled tomato ramen and Starbucks espresso in downtown Nagasaki.

“Scrumptious Japanese noodle, that for positive u will end the final drop of tomato soup. U will find it irresistible go and take a look at it,” Zhou wrote on Fb, the day the seventh individual from the Diamond Princess died. She didn’t reply to Reuters requests for remark.

Eight days later, after the primary coronavirus case was reported in Nagasaki, Mitsubishi and the Costa Atlantica operator requested the crew to remain on board.

That request additionally went unheeded. Greater than 30 individuals left and boarded the vessel from April 1 to 20, when the ship’s first case was detected and the motion stopped, mentioned native authorities official Futoshi Iwasaki.

A well being ministry official dealing with the Costa Atlantica advised Reuters the ministry “wasn’t ready to offer orders and we do not have the facility to implement them.”

Now of their cabins, the crew whereas away the time chatting with one another from their balconies and hand-washing their laundry.

Wholesome employees spray disinfectant across the ship. Footage shared with Reuters present one carrying a helmet, goggles and masks with a plastic bag over his torso as he distributes meals to colleagues.

“Persons are thanking me for working as a frontliner. And I’m joyful at hand over sugar and salt they want,” the Filipino crew member advised Reuters on situation of anonymity. “It’s my greatest nightmare.”

Related Posts